5/17/26 New York Yankees at New York Mets FREE MLB Picks and Predictions


5/17/26 New York Yankees at New York Mets FREE MLB Picks and Predictions


New York Yankees at New York Mets by Tony T.

Game Summary

The Subway Series gets a strong pitching matchup with Weathers showing the higher strikeout ceiling, while Peralta brings a solid ERA but slightly more walk risk.

The Pick

Mets have hit .226 on the season with an OBP of .293. Yankees have an OBP of .329 and .429 slugging percentage. Yankees bullpen has been outstanding on the road. Mets are 1-4 at home facing a team with a bullpen WHIP of 1.35 or lower with a -5.8-unit loss. Play Yankees -104.